Mamdani sues ‘NYC’s worst landlord’ for more than $10 million in first-of-its-kind lawsuit

Published on

Barry Singer was once officially the worst landlord in New York City. Public Advocate Jumaane Williams put him at No. 1 on his 2024 Worst Landlords Watchlist.

Now Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration is taking him to court.

On Wednesday, Mamdani announced that the city’s Law Department had filed a lawsuit in Bronx County Supreme Court seeking more than $10 million in damages and penalties from Singer, and asking the court to force repairs across 11 of his buildings in the Bronx and Brooklyn.

The twist is the law the city is using. For the first time, it’s going after a building owner under New York’s False Claims Act, the law that lets the government go after people who cheat it out of money. It’s usually aimed at contractors and health care providers, not landlords.

Here’s how that works. When a landlord won’t fix a dangerous problem, the city sends in its own crews for emergency repairs and pest control, then bills the owner. According to the lawsuit, Singer knowingly dodged more than $1.05 million of those charges and court judgments, plus interest. Under the False Claims Act, that can cost him triple damages and civil penalties of up to $28,619 per violation.

The city is also suing under its Nuisance Abatement Law, asking for $1,000 a day for each violation, and wants additional building code violations fixed.

The conditions laid out in the suit are frightening. Severely cracked and deteriorating facades. Bulging, leaning walls. Rusting fire escapes at risk of collapse. Unauthorized construction.

At 2500 Webb Avenue in the Bronx, the building has 456 violations, and 183 of them are classified as “immediately hazardous.” The lawsuit describes its facade as an “immediate hazard” with the “potential to collapse.”

At 3030 Heath Avenue, also in the Bronx, nobody can live there at all. The building has been under a full vacate order since a four-alarm fire on Jan. 15, 2025, and the city says Singer never complied with orders to repair the damage. Sections of the roof are missing, windows are gone, part of a loft has collapsed and there are problems with the gas valves. It has 261 violations, 105 of them immediately hazardous.

And the old approach wasn’t working. Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said his department had already hit Singer with a criminal court summons and “hundreds of thousands of dollars in penalties.”

“When the same old tools fail to deliver results, we will use new strategies to hold noncompliant landlords accountable and win justice for tenants,” Mamdani said. “Every New Yorker deserves a safe, well-maintained home, and we will use every tool at our disposal to make that a reality across the five boroughs.”

Corporation Counsel Steven Banks, the city’s top lawyer, pointed to how landlords like Singer operate. “Ignoring housing code violations and hiding behind shell companies has put both tenants and the public at risk,” he said.

Cea Weaver, who runs the Mayor’s Office to Protect Tenants, said that “in the Mamdani administration, City government is on tenants’ side.”

The city built this strategy with the legal advocacy group Housing Rights Initiative. It’s part of Fix the City, the administration’s push to make the city’s most chronic code violators follow the law or hand their buildings to owners who will. That push sits inside Block by Block, Mamdani’s housing plan to build 200,000 new affordable homes and preserve another 200,000 over the next decade, backed by $22 billion over five years.

For years, landlords like Singer have treated violations as a line item. Housing Preservation and Development Commissioner Dina Levy said the city is sending them a clear message that “subjecting tenants to hundreds of hazardous conditions is no longer an acceptable cost of doing business.”

Featured photo: Marc A. Hermann / MTA, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY 4.0. Resized.

Latest articles

Mamdani hits Trump with $400k tax bill under new pied-à-terre tax

Trump went Floridian on paper to cut his taxes, and now Mamdani's new second-home tax has handed his Trump Tower penthouse a $391,245 bill.

Hakeem Jeffries takes thousands from insurance industry, drops support for Medicare for All

When we reported that House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries dropped his support for Medicare...

This is Americans’ biggest concern about AI—and Republicans are blocking the fix

This is American’s biggest concern about AI—And Republicans Are Blocking The Fix

Mamdani’s progressive policies are driving crime to record lows in NYC

New York City just posted its safest seven months in recorded history — and...

More like this

Mamdani hits Trump with $400k tax bill under new pied-à-terre tax

Trump went Floridian on paper to cut his taxes, and now Mamdani's new second-home tax has handed his Trump Tower penthouse a $391,245 bill.

Hakeem Jeffries takes thousands from insurance industry, drops support for Medicare for All

When we reported that House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries dropped his support for Medicare...

This is Americans’ biggest concern about AI—and Republicans are blocking the fix

This is American’s biggest concern about AI—And Republicans Are Blocking The Fix